Poor Roof Maintenance: What Are the Risks for Your Insurance Premiums?

In Canada, your home's roof plays a much more important role than you might think in your home insurance coverage. Not only does it protect your house from the elements, but its overall condition can also influence the cost of your premium—or even jeopardize certain coverages in the event of a claim.
Let’s take a closer look at why a poorly maintained roof can be costly and how to avoid it.
🏠 Why Is the Condition of the Roof Important to Insurers?
The roof is one of the most critical components of a building’s structure. A roof in poor condition significantly increases the risk of:
- Water damage (leaks, mold, ceiling and wall damage);
- Partial or total collapse, especially in winter due to snow accumulation;
- Wind damage if shingles are deteriorated or missing.
These risks represent potentially high costs for insurers. That’s why many companies ask for specific information about the age, materials, and maintenance of your roof before offering you coverage.
💸 How Does It Affect Your Insurance Premium?
Here are a few ways a poorly maintained roof can impact your home insurance policy:
- Higher Insurance Premium : An old or damaged roof presents an increased risk for the insurer. This can lead to a higher premium.
- Coverage Limitations : Some companies may refuse to cover water damage if the roof is deemed too old (often more than 20 or 25 years) or poorly maintained.
- Denied Claim in Case of Damage : If water infiltration occurs and the insurer observes clear neglect (unreplaced torn shingles, no inspections, visible signs of deterioration ignored), your claim may be partially or fully denied.
- Policy Non-Renewal or Refusal : An insurer may refuse to renew your policy or offer a new contract if the roof is in very poor condition. They might also exclude roof-related damages until the roof is repaired or replaced.
🔎 What Do Insurers Look at During Evaluation?
Insurers may ask for:
- The year the roof was built or last redone;
- The type of roofing material used (asphalt shingles, metal, elastomeric membrane, etc.). The roofing material can influence the premium, as some materials are riskier during storms. For example, vinyl sidings are more prone to being blown away by wind, leading to third-party damage or water infiltration. Metal roofs, on the other hand, pose a higher liability risk since snow or ice can slide off and injure someone.
- Recent exterior photos of your home;
- A building inspection (sometimes required at the time of underwriting).
✅ Best Practices to Protect Your Roof... and Your Wallet
- Inspect your roof twice a year, in spring and fall;
- Quickly replace any missing or damaged shingles;
- Clear snow accumulation in winter if necessary;
- Don’t wait for an emergency to plan a roof replacement, especially if your roof is nearing the end of its lifespan.
🛠️ Need a New Roof? Get Quotes Quickly with our partner Reno Quotes!
If your roof shows signs of aging or deterioration, it may be time to replace it. This could not only protect your home but also help you get a better home insurance rate.
👉 Submit a free quote request for roof replacement on our partner website Renoquotes.com. In just a few clicks, you’ll receive offers from qualified contractors in your area.
In Summary
Maintaining your roof is essential not only for your home’s safety but also to preserve your insurance coverage and keep your premiums affordable. Don’t underestimate the financial impact of a torn shingle or a neglected leak.
Be proactive: inspect, repair, and if needed, plan a replacement with reputable professionals.